Does It Make More Sense to Put CHEMICALLY ADDICTED People in PRISON for POSSESSION or in REHAB?
Question by Bush is not conservative: Does it make more sense to put CHEMICALLY ADDICTED people in PRISON for POSSESSION or in REHAB?
Addiction is an illness. Narcotics abuse is an illness. Logically, the purchasing, possession and abuse of a drug by an addict is as much of a health concern as it is a legal one.
Narcotics abuse is undoubtedly a more emotionally complicated crime than other nonviolent offenses such as theft and vandalism, but early attempts to curb abuse lacked the necessary breadth to get addicts clean. Incarceration is not an effective method of freeing drug users from the substances on which they depend.
You cannot always beat a beast into submission, and the national “war on drugs,” as it is currently framed, attempts to do just that. It aims to prevent drug abuse and crimes through the enforcement of strict, blanketed penalties for citizens who violate.
Although national policies on drug prohibition state the goal is to promote public health, more funding, both on a national and local level, is allocated toward criminal investigations and prosecution of drug users than toward education and rehabilitation.
The fruitless brute-force methods established at a federal level are also standard at the local level. The Los Angeles Police Department made 26,131 arrests for violent and property-related crimes in 2003, according to a statistical report released by the chief of police.
The same year, the LAPD made 27,486 narcotics arrests. In short, police officers arrested 1,300 more citizens for narcotics violations than for murders, rapes, thefts, aggravated assaults and larcenies combined.
Despite the widespread arrests for narcotics-defined crimes in 2003, the effects the arrests had on usage was negligible. According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the number of adult users and abusers remained at a flat line.
Crime statistics show that harsh sentencing for nonviolent drug possession convictions is ineffective in deterring repeat offenses, but further analysis reveals that incarceration for those first offenses could increase the probably of a second offense. Relapse rates are more than 70 percent from all forms of criminal justice interventions and corrections-oriented approaches alone, according to the U.N. Office on Drug and Crime.
California took a step in the right direction in November of 2000 when it passed Proposition 36 – the initiative that allows people with first- and second-time drug possession convictions to receive drug treatment instead of incarceration – but implementation and funding issues have prevented the proposition from being wholly successful.
Officials at the district attorney’s office told the L.A. Weekly that they had expected the primary patients enrolling in the rehabilitation programs to be recreational users – not full-blown addicts. The money allocated to fund rehabilitation programs and medical treatment is insufficient for the more typical, heavily addicted individuals who frequently require longer, more expensive treatments in residential facilities instead of 12-step outpatient program.
Recent state and county cutbacks have been devastating to already strained programs made possible by Prop. 36. To further complicate matters, the sheer size of the county coupled with the lack of money makes proper regulation of the program near impossible to assess.
According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, effective drug treatment programs combine the necessary medical aid and social services required to get the addicted individual back on track. Prop. 36 has made headway in providing Californians in need with a chance at restored chemical freedom, but without additional well-funded social welfare programs such as job placement services, access to medical and mental health treatment facilities, and counseling services, the success of the legislation is extremely limited.
A more compassionate solution to the drug problem is not only more humane, it’s more cost effective. Every dollar spent on drug and alcohol abuse treatment saves the public $ 7, according study findings released by the state in 1994.
To successfully combat drug abuse and drug-related crime in California, the state needs to ensure that allocating funding for rehabilitation programs is a priority.
In addition to the court-mandated programs created by Prop. 36, the city needs to make comprehensive voluntary rehabilitation programs accessible to drug addicts who want to change before they’re picked up by the police. The earlier people are given a hand to make the change, the sooner they will.
It’s easy to demonize drug addicts and dismiss jail sentences that still too frequently follow possession convictions, but blame doesn’t create change.
An addict with hopeless prospects has a hard time finding motivation to get clean, but if the society around that addict is willing to offer guidance, support and the promise of brighter future for the willing, the incentive to get sober suddenly becomes tangible .
Compassion must become a fundamental element in the rehabilitation system, and compassion starts with understanding. Prop. 36 was a great start, but there’s still a long road ahead.
Best answer:
Answer by civil_av8r
There’s a big difference between using drugs and pushing drugs. Prison should be for the latter.
Give your answer to this question below!
Pittsburgh Occupational Health Services, Robinson PA Employee Health Assesment – Call now 412-494-4550 www.alleghenymedical.com Helping You Select & Build a Healthier Workforce While Reducing Injuries & Cost. – Assisting employers in the hiring process by performing pre- and post-offer job specific physicals and substance abuse screenings. – Helping employers protect their most valuable assets – their employees. – Protecting your employees health, preventing illness and injury and ensuring safety – Providing the best medical treatment possible, enabling employees to return to work as soon as safely possible. The WorkCare medical team at Allegheny Medical consists of specially trained physicians, nurses, physical therapists, and rehabilitation specialists who provide injured employees the highest quality, most cost effective occupational health care. Our expert physicians provide immediate medical care to injured employees enabling them to return to work as soon as safely possible. WorkCare is a preferred panel provider for hundreds of companies, municipalities, and school districts throughout the tri-state area. Occupational Health Services * Routine/Annual Physicals * Department of Transportation (DOT) Physicals * Work-Site Evaluation and Job Analysis * Verbal Clearance * Medical Review Officer (MRO) Service * Development of Panel Provider List * Work Hardening * Injury Treatment * Minor Emergency Care * Injury Follow-up * Physical Therapy * Return to Work * Injury Status Reports Full Service Laboratory * Urine Drug Screening (NIDA-Approved 48-72 Hrs …
Iowa children face greatest risk of abuse in their earliest years
Filed under: drug abuse treatment cost analysis program
Adverse childhood experiences include emotional, physical or sexual abuse; emotional or physical neglect; a mother who is treated violently; mental illness or substance abuse in the household; an incarcerated household member; or parental separation …
Read more on DesMoinesRegister.com
mental health facility sought
Filed under: drug abuse treatment cost analysis program
The state budget proposal also includes a program to divert those with mental health problems from prisons and jails where they often don't get adequate care and are likely to return, crossing the law again if not treated. "It appears jails and prisons …
Read more on Las Vegas Review – Journal
Doctors asked to participate in gun debate
Filed under: drug abuse treatment cost analysis program
Like those two illegal drugs, tobacco has absolutely zero redeeming societal or health benefits. All it does is create health problems, poor air, higher insurance and medical costs, secondhand smoke issues, unsightly public areas, and death. Of course …
Read more on CNN (blog)